Duties in Regard to Things Indifferent
C. Hodge, D.D. Romans 14:22-23 Have you faith? have it to yourself before God. Happy is he that comdemns not himself in that thing which he allows.… Some things are unlawful in their own nature, and can never be right. Others are wrong because forbidden, and only as long as the prohibition continues, and only to the parties concerned. Others are wrong on the ground of expediency, and therefore are sometimes wrong and sometimes right. It is not always easy to discriminate these classes. I. THERE ARE, however, CERTAIN CRITERIA BY WHICH WE CAN DISTINGUISH THE NATURALLY WRONG FROM THE NATURALLY INDIFFERENT. 1. One of these is to be found in our moral constitution. We can see intuitively that malice, envy, pride, etc., are in their nature wrong. They are evil, not because they are forbidden, nor because of their injurious tendency, but they are essentially evil. 2. The Scriptures condemn such things as are in their nature evil, not for one people, nor for a limited period, but for all men always. II. FOR THINGS INDIFFERENT IN THEIR NATURE THE SCRIPTURES LAY DOWN THE FOLLOWING RULES. 1. If prohibited for any special reason, they are unlawful while that prohibition lasts. 2. When the prohibition is removed, they are right or wrong according to circumstances. (1) They are wrong when their use or enjoyment would do harm to others. (2) They are right when no such evil is to be apprehended. (3) That principle is never to be sacrificed to expediency, i.e., when doing or not doing anything would imply the denial of an important truth. All these principles are illustrated by the apostle's conduct and teaching. These were circumcision, observance of Jewish holy days, and eating meats prohibited by the Mosaic law, or which had been offered to idols. Paul taught — (a) That there was no harm in doing or neglecting them. If a man chose to circumcise his son, or to keep a holy day, or to abstain from certain meats, he was free to do so. (b) That he must not make his judgment a rule of duty to others. He must not condemn those who thought or acted differently (ver. 4). (c) But if any of these things became a source of evil, caused the weak to offend, then the law of love forbids our indulging in them, or availing ourselves of our Christian liberty, (d) But if any of these things were urged as a matter of duty, or a condition of salvation, then it became a sin to make them necessary. Paul, therefore, although he circumcised Timothy, refused to allow Titus to be circumcised. It is difficult to determine whether compliance with the prejudices of others is right or wrong. Our Lord disregarded Jewish prejudices in regard to the Sabbath. In other cases He complied in order to avoid giving offence. III. THERE ARE CERTAIN PRINCIPLES IMPORTANT TO HAVE FIXED AS GUIDES OF CONDUCT. 1. Nothing is right or wrong which is not commanded or forbidden in Scripture. 2. We must stand fast in the liberty wherewith Christ has made us free, and not allow any rule of duty to be imposed on us. 3. In the use of this liberty, and while asserting and maintaining it, we should not so use it as to do harm to our neighbours. 4. Nothing indifferent can be a proper ground of Church discipline or a condition of Church fellowship. These principles are often violated, as in the course pursued by many on slavery, temperance, tobacco, dress, Church ceremonies, etc. (C. Hodge, D.D.) Parallel Verses KJV: Hast thou faith? have it to thyself before God. Happy is he that condemneth not himself in that thing which he alloweth. WEB: Do you have faith? Have it to yourself before God. Happy is he who doesn't judge himself in that which he approves.