the LORD said to Samuel.
The LORD's communication with Samuel underscores the prophet's role as God's intermediary. Samuel, a judge and prophet, is a key figure during this transitional period. His relationship with God is reminiscent of Moses, who also received direct guidance from the LORD. This divine instruction highlights God's sovereignty and His willingness to allow human agency, even when it diverges from His ideal plan.

“Appoint a king for them.”
God's directive to appoint a king is both a concession and a judgment. While it fulfills the people's request, it also serves as a test of their faithfulness. The appointment of a king is prophesied in Deuteronomy 17:14-20, where God provides guidelines for a king who would lead according to His laws. This moment foreshadows the coming of Jesus Christ, the ultimate King, who perfectly embodies God's will and reigns with justice and righteousness.

Then Samuel told the men of Israel,
Samuel's role as a leader and prophet is evident as he communicates God's decision to the people. His obedience to God's command, despite his personal reservations (1 Samuel 8:6), demonstrates his faithfulness. This act of communication is crucial in maintaining the covenant relationship between God and Israel, as Samuel serves as the bridge between divine will and human action.

“Everyone must go back to his city.”
This instruction signifies the conclusion of the assembly where the demand for a king was made. It reflects the decentralized nature of Israelite society at the time, where people lived in tribal territories. The dispersal to their cities indicates a return to daily life, but with the anticipation of a significant change in governance. This moment sets the stage for the anointing of Saul as the first king, which will bring both unity and challenges to the nation of Israel.

“Listen to their voice,” the LORD said to Samuel.

• The request for a king was not a passing whim; it reflected Israel’s determination to be “like all the other nations” (1 Samuel 8:5).

• God had already foreseen this day and allowed for it in Deuteronomy 17:14-15, proving that nothing surprises Him.

• By telling Samuel to listen, the LORD grants the people what they insist on, yet it is a sober concession, much like Psalm 106:15 describes: “So He gave them what they asked, but sent a wasting disease among them.”

• Hosea 13:11 later echoes this moment: “I gave you a king in My anger and took him away in My wrath,” underscoring that permission is not always approval.

• The literal narrative shows God respecting human choice while still reigning sovereign over its outcome.

“Appoint a king for them.”

• God moves from permission to instruction: Samuel must act.

• Saul will soon be selected (1 Samuel 9:17), proving the LORD’s hand guides even a reluctant plan.

• Yet this step also advances His redemptive timeline; the monarchy leads to David (2 Samuel 7:12-16), and ultimately to Christ, “the Son of David” (Luke 1:32-33).

• Judges 21:25 notes, “In those days there was no king in Israel; everyone did what was right in his own eyes.” The rise of a king addresses that chaos, though it cannot cure the deeper issue of the heart (Jeremiah 17:9).

• God’s instruction is literal: Israel will have a flesh-and-blood ruler, but the Lord remains King above all (Psalm 47:7-8).

“Then Samuel told the men of Israel,”

• The prophet faithfully relays God’s word, modeling obedience (1 Samuel 3:19-21).

• Like Moses reporting to Israel at Sinai (Exodus 19:7-8), Samuel stands between God and the people—prophet as mediator.

• Jeremiah 1:7 reminds that a prophet must “speak whatever I command you.” Samuel does exactly that, even when the message grieves him (1 Samuel 8:6).

• His transparency allows the nation to understand the gravity of their request and the steps to come.

“Everyone must go back to his city.”

• The assembly disperses until God reveals the chosen king.

• Joshua 22:6 shows a similar dismissal after weighty decisions, emphasizing order and peace.

• Practically, the directive avoids mob excitement; spiritually, it gives space for reflection and repentance.

• Soon Samuel will summon them again to install Saul (1 Samuel 11:14). Until then, daily life continues, but under the shadow of a major shift in Israel’s governance.

• 2 Samuel 20:22 illustrates how returning home can end immediate tension but keep God’s plan moving forward.

God grants Israel’s persistent demand for a king, not because the request is best, but to let them taste the consequences and to advance His greater purpose. He tells Samuel to listen, appoint, announce, and dismiss. The passage highlights divine sovereignty, human responsibility, and the unfolding path toward the ultimate King, Jesus Christ.

So now, with the self-same words with which He had spoken to the seer when at the first he laid the petition of Israel before the eternal throne, He finally directs Samuel respecting the course of action he was to pursue on this momentous occasion.

The men of Israel.--That is, to the elders. The words which follow, "Go ye every man unto his city," show that these elders were in truth a representative body, drawn from the chief centres of the land.

Attention has already been drawn to the perfect trust which the Eternal must have placed in Samuel the judge, seeing that He entrusted him with all the arrangements connected with this vital change in the Hebrew constitution, although his own downfall from power was necessarily involved in it. The confidence of the God-Friend of Israel in their upright judge was evidently shared in by the people. It was to their ruler, to the earthly head of their republic, that they in the first instance carried, through their representative chiefs, their request, which in other words said, "Let kings for the future, and not judges like yourself, rule over us." The elders of Israel seem to have listened respectfully to the urgent remonstrances of their great judge, and to have deliberated carefully over them, and then, still respectfully, but firmly, to have reiterated their first request, which asked for a king instead of a judge. Again they watched him go alone into the presence of the Eternal, and after the seer's solitary prayer, the "elders," at the bidding of their judge, dispersed quietly, each one journeying to his own city. They loved and trusted the patriot Samuel, and though they were ready to depose him, they waited till he should give them a sign.

Parallel Commentaries ...